A post composed between January and March of this year, never published, perhaps through a fear that once I start to describe my stronger opinions I open myself up to critique... but do you know what? I really don't mind. This is a topic I think is of great importance, and critique can only deepen my own understanding through further questioning, so go ahead....
This blog isn’t intended to be an intellectual rhetoric or
polemic. Just my thoughts and feelings as I immerse myself in a year farming,
and the consequences of those reactions on my choices in life. I have refrained
thus far from writing to seriously on the matter of food and farming however, I
began to write a piece in early January just after I had been to a conference
and listened to an inspiring talk on soil health. The talk focussed on the
nutrient levels found within our land and consequential uptake of those passed
on directly through our food system.
We are bombarded with information on diets and how we should
eat in order to be healthy. In my household I was certainly aware of calories
from a very young age, and later salt, cholesterol and now sugar have become
important considerations for various family members’ wellbeing. Whilst at
university I spent more time with people who considered natural remedies. Local
honey for hayfever, plants rather than their chemically controlled extracts for
common complaints – a controversial topic I know.
At a really basic level though I had never spent any
significant time thinking about the carrot I was eating, for example, where it
had grown, and what quality of soil it might be in. This now seems wondrous to
me, what could be more important than the quality of the basic food we feed our
bodies with. If I had to eat five carrots today to find the same nutritional
value as someone in my family might have done fifty years ago there seems to be
a problem somewhere. So why aren’t we all talking about this over the dinner
table instead of how many weight watchers points our meals contain?
To those who may see this way of thinking as an old
fashioned or hippy in its ideal I can affirm to you that the speakers at this
particular talk were of established professional backgrounds, scientific,
academic and more practical. A focal concern was that the present drive for
yield and appearance neglects the mineral content of our produce. The complex mix of nutrients required for
healthy plant growth goes a long way beyond common agricultural fertiliser; and
those artificial fertilisers often leave our land wanting, making farmers
dependent on their use.
I have witnessed how difficult farming without chemical
assistance can be, and I appreciate the grand scale of providing food for our
population. However, I do feel that the quality rather than the quantity of the
food we are producing and consuming is paramount to our own health. The word
organic has a hundred negative connotations which I won't even begin to discuss
here, but please consider what has gone into produce your fruits and
vegetables, and what state the land they departed is in. We are after all a direct product of what we eat.
Taste has brought this very question to my mind on more than one occasion. Perhaps because in Sichuan it seemed every available space was being used to grow something, and the white cabbage and some of the gourds eaten over here do taste very earthy. Tasting the earth has made me wonder what kind of earth they are grown in, and if that matters to anything more than taste. Thank you for providing pointers to research suggesting that it does matter.
ReplyDeleteSince my days collecting wild foods I remember reading in "Food for Free" that the common 'weed' fat-hen "contains more iron and protein than either cabbage or spinach, and more vitamin B1 and calcium than raw cabbage." I also remember reading/hearing that old varieties of apples are more nutritious. After a quick search, I've found this news article:
http://www.metro.co.uk/news/895861-old-fruit-could-be-better-for-you-than-new-fruit-says-new-research
From what you say, soil health has an even more important part to play if we're to continue providing our growing population with all the nutrients we need: It doesn't matter how efficient a plant is at extracting nutrients from the soil if the nutrients aren't there in the first place or, heaven forbid, nothing can be grown on it.